Water Heater Installation

How to Compare Water Heater Replacement Quotes in Wilmington

Water Heater Now Team

Licensed Delaware Plumbers, Licence PL-0002475, Serving Wilmington and the Tri-State Area

Published November 18, 2026

Two ruled sheets laid side by side on a kitchen table with a pen and a calculator, ready for comparing water heater replacement quotes
Two quotes are only comparable once every line on them is filled in.

To compare water heater replacement quotes, put them side by side and check each line: the exact model and capacity, what the installation covers (expansion tank, valves, venting, permit, removal of the old tank), any after-hours or weekend fee, and whether the price is fixed before work starts. Two quotes are only comparable once every one of those lines is filled in, so ask each company to fill in what is missing before you decide.

Why Two Quotes Rarely Match

Most Wilmington homeowners who get two or three quotes for the same job find a spread of several hundred dollars, sometimes more. That gap is rarely one company being greedy and the other being generous. It is usually two different jobs written on two different pieces of paper.

One quote includes the expansion tank, the permit and hauling the old tank away. Another lists the heater and "labor" and nothing else. One prices a 40-gallon tank and another a 50. One is a fixed price and another is an hourly estimate. Until those differences are lined up, the lowest number tells you very little.

The Federal Trade Commission's advice on home repairs puts it plainly: "Get multiple estimates," "Don't automatically choose the lowest bidder," and "ask for an explanation if there's a big difference among the estimates." This guide is the list of questions that gets you that explanation.

Line 1: The Heater Itself

Start with the equipment, because everything else depends on it. Each quote should name:

  • The brand and model number, not just "50-gallon electric." Model numbers let you compare the warranty and efficiency of the actual unit.
  • The capacity in gallons for a tank, and whether it matches what you have now or what your household needs. Our guide to what size water heater you need explains how to check.
  • The fuel and vent type: electric, gas with a standard metal flue, or a power-vent gas unit. These are different products at different prices.

If one quote says "50-gallon electric, Bradford White, model BRWRE350S6-1NCWW" and another just says "electric water heater," call the second company and ask for the model number. A written estimate, in the FTC's words, "should include a description of the work to be done, materials, completion date, and the price."

What the Installation Line Should Cover

This is where cheap quotes save money on paper. A complete replacement in New Castle County usually includes several parts that a bare quote leaves out, and each one shows up later as an extra charge if it is not listed now. Ask each company to confirm, line by line, whether the price includes:

  • Removing and hauling away the old tank. Draining, carrying it up the basement stairs and disposing of it is real work. Ask whether it is included or billed separately.
  • An expansion tank. Many Delaware homes need one where the water system is closed. Our post on water heater expansion tanks explains why. A quote without one may come back with it as an add-on.
  • Shutoff valves and connectors. Are new valves and supply lines included, or priced on site? Either is fair, as long as you know which before you sign.
  • The relief valve discharge pipe run to code, not left short or capped.
  • The permit. Rules differ inside Wilmington city limits and in the rest of New Castle County, and again in Chester County, PA and Cecil County, MD. Ask who pulls the permit and whether its cost is in the price.
  • Drain pan, if the heater sits where a leak could damage a finished floor.

A quote that answers "included" to most of these and lists the rest with a price is a quote you can trust. A quote that answers "we'll see when we get there" to all of them is an estimate, not a price.

For the record, here is how ours reads: a 50-gallon Bradford White electric is $2,198 installed and a 40-gallon Bradford White gas is $2,498 installed, each with the expansion tank and haul-away included. Valves are extra and priced on site, and vent repairs on a gas unit are priced separately if they are needed. Our installation cost guide walks through what drives the price up or down.

A new tank water heater with an expansion tank, shutoff valve and relief valve discharge pipe installed in a basement
The expansion tank, valves and relief valve piping are where cheap quotes usually leave things out.

Gas Tanks: Ask About the Vent

On a gas water heater, the vent is the line most likely to change the final bill. The flue carries combustion gases out of your home, and an old, rusted or poorly sloped vent connector has to be put right before a new heater goes on it.

Ask each company two questions:

1. Does the price include connecting the new heater to the existing vent? 2. If the vent needs repair, how is that priced, and will you tell me before you do it?

A company that has looked at photos of your heater or come out to see it can answer this properly. One that quotes a gas replacement over the phone without asking about the vent may be leaving the biggest variable off the page. Our gas water heater replacement cost post covers what else can add to a gas job.

Metal flue pipe rising from the top of a gas water heater toward the chimney connection in a basement
On a gas tank, the vent connection is the line most likely to change the final price.

Fixed Price or Hourly Estimate

Next, check how each company actually charges. There are two models:

  • A fixed price. You see one number for the job, you approve it, and that is what you pay unless you agree to a change.
  • Hourly plus parts. The quote is an estimate of time and materials. The real number is known only when the job ends.

A fixed price is much easier to compare, because you are comparing finished numbers. If one of your quotes is hourly, ask for a not-to-exceed figure so the two can be lined up. Then read the small print for fees that only apply sometimes. We charge additional fees for after-hours and weekend service, and we say so before booking. Ask every company the same question so the comparison is fair.

Need water heater service in Wilmington?

Serving Wilmington with same-day availability and flat-rate pricing confirmed before work begins.

Timing, Payment and Paperwork

The last lines are the ones that decide how the day goes.

  • When can they do it? If your old tank is leaking, a quote for next week is not the same offer as one for today. Many companies, ours included, offer same-day appointments, and a standard tank swap usually takes two to three hours. Our same-day water heater replacement post explains what makes a same-day job possible.
  • How do they want to be paid? The FTC warns that scammers "ask you to pay for everything up front or only accept cash," and advises: "Don't pay the full amount for the project up front." For a job done in one visit, paying when the hot water is back on is normal.
  • Financing. If you plan to spread the cost, compare the monthly figure and the terms, not just the headline number. Ours is $80 a month for the electric install or $89 a month for the gas install, on approved credit.
  • The licence number on the quote. The FTC says to "consider only contractors who are licensed and insured" and to check the licence with your state. In Delaware you can look it up on the Division of Professional Regulation's Verify License Online search. Ours is PL-0002475.

A Side-by-Side Checklist

Copy this list and fill one column per company. Any blank square is a question to ask before you choose.

LineQuote AQuote B
Brand and model number
Capacity and fuel
Expansion tank included?
Valves and connectors included or priced?
Vent connection and repair pricing (gas)
Permit included?
Old tank removal and haul-away included?
Fixed price or hourly estimate
After-hours or weekend fee
Earliest install date
Payment terms and financing
Delaware licence number

When every square is filled, the comparison usually becomes obvious. The quotes that looked far apart often land close together, and the one that looked cheapest is sometimes the one with the most blanks.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is one water heater quote so much cheaper than another?

Usually because it covers less. Check whether the cheaper quote includes the expansion tank, valves, permit and haul-away, and whether it is a fixed price or an hourly estimate. The FTC advises asking for an explanation whenever estimates differ a lot.

Should I get a quote over the phone or in person?

A phone quote works for a like-for-like swap when the company knows the model you have and what is around it. Photos of the heater, the vent and the pipes above it help. Fuel switches, moves to a new location and tankless conversions need a visit.

Do I need a permit to replace a water heater in New Castle County?

Rules differ between Wilmington city limits, the rest of New Castle County and the neighbouring states, so ask each company whether the permit is included and who applies for it. We handle the permit for your address.

Can I compare a tank quote with a tankless quote?

Not directly. They are different equipment with different installation work. Our guide to tankless vs tank water heaters helps you decide which one to quote first.

Get a Quote You Can Compare

Water Heater Now publishes its installed prices so you can line them up against anyone else's: $2,198 for a 50-gallon Bradford White electric and $2,498 for a 40-gallon Bradford White gas water heater, expansion tank and haul-away included, with a flat price you approve before work starts. Call (302) 240-2818 or see our water heater installation and replacement service in Wilmington for what every install covers. We serve New Castle County, Chester County, PA and Cecil County, MD.

---

Sources, verified November 18, 2026: Federal Trade Commission, How To Avoid a Home Improvement Scam; Delaware Division of Professional Regulation, Verify License Online. Installed prices and financing are Water Heater Now's published flat rate as of November 2026.

Need a Licensed Technician?

Water Heater Now serves Wilmington, New Castle County, Chester County, and Cecil County. Call for a flat-rate price confirmed before work begins.

Open 24 hours, 7 days a week

No hot water?CallText